Home / Articles / Headhunters: Who They Are, What They Do, and Whether They're for You
Headhunters: Who They Are, What They Do, and Whether They're for You
The word sounds adversarial, like someone is coming for you. In practice, an executive recruiter is one of the more useful people you can have in your corner during a senior nonprofit search, as long as you understand what they do and who they work for.
What a recruiter actually does
A search consultant is hired by an organization to fill a specific role. They define that role with the employer, find and screen candidates, run the first round of interviews, and present a short list of finalists. They are paid by the organization, which means the organization is their client. You are not.
That single fact explains almost everything about how the relationship works. A recruiter is not your agent, and a reputable one will never charge you to be placed. They are a professional hired to solve someone else's hiring problem, and you are one of the people who might solve it.
Retained or contingency
There are two common models, and knowing which one you are dealing with tells you how the relationship runs. A retained firm is paid by the employer to conduct a search whether or not a hire is ultimately made, and tends to handle senior and executive roles exclusively for that client. A contingency recruiter is paid only if their candidate lands the job, and often works higher-volume or more junior roles. Nonprofit and mission-driven executive searches are usually retained.
What that means for you
Because the recruiter works for the employer, your job is to make their job easy. Be responsive. Be honest about your experience, your timing, and your salary expectations, because a recruiter who trusts you becomes your advocate to the client, and one who catches you shading the truth quietly stops returning calls. Treat every interaction as part of the evaluation, because it is.
How to get on a recruiter's radar
Be findable and be specific. Keep your LinkedIn current and clear about the kind of role and mission you want, so that when a relevant search opens, you surface. Build relationships before you need them, respond quickly when a recruiter reaches out, and stay in touch even when you are not looking. Recruiters keep notes. The candidate who was gracious and helpful on a search last year is the one who gets the first call this year.
When a recruiter is, and is not, the right path
Most nonprofit roles, especially at the mid level, are filled through postings, networking, and direct applications, not through search firms. Recruiters concentrate on senior and executive seats and on hard-to-fill specialized roles. So a recruiter is one channel, not the channel. Keep applying directly, keep networking, and let recruiter relationships add to your search rather than replace it.
Working with a recruiter, in one minute:
- They work for the employer, not for you. Be genuinely useful to them anyway.
- Be honest about experience, timing, and pay. Trust is the entire relationship.
- Respond quickly and follow through.
- Most roles are not filled by search firms, so keep your own search active.
- Stay in touch between searches. The relationship compounds.
The bottom line
A recruiter is not a gatekeeper to fear or a fairy godmother to wait on. They are a professional with a job to do. Help them do it well, and you become the candidate they remember, recommend, and call first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I pay a headhunter to find me a job?
No. Executive recruiters are paid by the hiring organization, not by candidates. Be cautious with anyone who asks you to pay a fee to be placed in a job.
What is the difference between retained and contingency recruiters?
A retained firm is paid by the employer to run a search to completion and usually handles senior and executive roles. A contingency recruiter is paid only when their candidate is hired. Nonprofit executive searches are typically retained.
How do I get executive recruiters to notice me?
Keep your LinkedIn current and specific, be clear about the roles and missions you want, respond promptly, and build relationships before you need them. Referrals from people a recruiter already trusts help most.
Should I rely only on recruiters for my job search?
No. Most roles, especially at the mid level, are filled through postings, networking, and direct applications. Treat recruiter relationships as one channel among several and keep your own search active.
Running a senior search of your own?
Whether you are mapping your next move or sharpening how you show up to recruiters, the search professionals at ExecSearches can help. We have done this since 1999, with highly individualized service and no wasted motion.